Twelve interplanetary dust grains collected by NASA's Cosmic Dust program have provided the first direct evidence of a heavy water reservoir beyond Neptune, according to a paper published in Science Advances by researchers at NASA's Johnson Space Center and UCLA.
The dust grains originated in the Kuiper Belt, confirmed by counting solar energetic particle tracks left by high-energy radiation during their journey to Earth. Analysis revealed the grains contained clays made with water and four times more carbon than expected for primitive meteorites, indicating liquid water once flowed inside their parent objects in the outer solar system.
Lead author Lindsay Keller's team measured oxygen isotope ratios in the clay samples and used chemical modeling to determine the original water composition. The primordial Kuiper Belt objects were extraordinarily enriched with oxygen-17 and oxygen-18 compared to oxygen-16, the most common isotope in the Sun and inner solar system.
This solves a long-standing mystery. The 2011 Genesis mission found the Sun contains overwhelming amounts of oxygen-16, while Earth, Mars, and the asteroid belt have much more of the heavier isotopes. The carbon monoxide self-shielding theory explains this. Around 4.5 billion years ago, ultraviolet light broke apart carbon monoxide molecules in the outer protoplanetary disk differently than in the inner disk, allowing heavier oxygen isotopes to concentrate in the outer regions and form with hydrogen into heavy water.
The paper also explains why this outer water reservoir never migrated inward. Saturn's gravity created a high-pressure ridge in the early protoplanetary disk that acted as a barrier, preventing lightweight material from being pulled toward the Sun.